Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

That's the opposite of what I expect but, since it is entirely possible that video + text does outperform text, there's A/B tests running to that effect.



Just bought the course and I'm downloading some of the videos because I watch most of my videos on the go (ie., in the car or on my ipad).

First impressions (ie., first 60 seconds on the course), it really seems like something created for a person sitting at a computer to watch it all. I wish there was a downloadable zip file I could download all the videos at once. I'm trying to download the videos now and I'm running into all sorts of errors and such (I think it's only letting me download one video at a time). Actually I'm getting error messages right now for all the pages. Is your site down?

Update: Ok, it looks like it's back up and running. When I download videos and try to right-click to save mp4 file, it downloads an html file and not the video. I need to go into the video to watch it and then option-return the url to start downloading. Very strange. This happens to the opt-in videos in lesson 2. optins-teardowns video doesn't seem to be downloading at all.

Also, your video sizes are really large. Example, 235mb for an 8:10 minute video (1024x768 resolution). You should be able to get the file size down to 100mb or so. For comparison, Kevin Rose's interview of Dennis Crowley in 720p is about the same size, 237mb, but the interview is about 20 minutes.

Your copywriting video is 686mb for 19:53 length... compared with Kevin Rose's Dennis Crowley video of 235mb for 19:20 length. That makes your video 3x the size of Kevin Rose's video (which is great 720p quality).

Honestly, this is a really sucky first experience. This is going to take my all morning to download these videos because the file sizes are 2-3x what they should be and because the links aren't all working.

And then after I download the videos, since they're so large I'm going to have a hard time fitting them in my iPhone and iPad. Please investigate getting your file sizes down. I think you can shrink the file sizes of your mp4 video to 1/3 the current size but keep the same resolution/quality.

Update: Your optins-teardowns.mp4 file is absent. I can't download it. Please fix cause I don't want to watch the lessons out of order.


I'm looking into why it can't find that file. In the meanwhile, I'll send you a direct link.


Actually, it just got fixed a minute ago. I was able to download it.


Update: patio11 is 3x bigger than Kevin Rose. dave1619 compares girth.


Patrick, that video is far too long and does a lot to damage your perceived value. At a number of points you wander off into "includes material on...", rather than "solve X problem using some means" language.

You repeatedly drum into people that they shouldn't be just rails programmers who know skills foo, bar and baz, but rather people who solve business problems. You forgot that lesson in the video.

I'm not at the stage with my business that this'll be useful - but will be soon enough and email will be my primary sales channel. Otherwise this does look like excellent material.

Note, my criticism comes from a place of love. It's your first attempt and feedback will help you improve. Best of luck.


In multiple tests, I have seen the video + long sales copy move the needle as much as 70% on final sales. As of yet, I have not run a test that does not increase by at least 20%. Details NDA, YMMV




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: