Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The JVM does this pretty well for Minecraft. I doubt Minecraft would support Linux, the BSDs, etc without it. Bedrock edition (the not-JVM version which supports Windows and consoles/phones) doesn't even support MacOS even though it obviously could.



If Minecraft were a Microsoft product from the start, they probably wouldn't have made the Java version compatible with Mac or Linux (even though it uses JVM, there are some natives included), or wouldn't have made a Java version to begin with.


Also it’s pretty ironic that Microsoft, who wants to convince the entire world that c#/netcore is the next multi-os platform isn’t capable of delivering anything else than Minecraft Java on Linux.

It’s a shame that I can’t play with my son from my Linux PC since he plays on switch (so the c#/bedrock edition)


> It’s a shame that I can’t play with my son from my Linux PC since he plays on switch (so the c#/bedrock edition)

There are some plugins for the java edition server that allow bedrock clients to join, that might be an option for you.


Oh nice ! I’ll check that !


Bedrock edition is written in C++ and does not use C#.


Oh, didn’t know that, thanks !


If it were, targeting all platforms would have been fairly easy (assuming it would still rely on OpenGL), sometimes just specifying RID e.g. `linux-arm64`.


They could target Linux fine with their C++ code, they actually have secret builds for Linux for Marketplace creators (they have been leaked occasionally) but they don’t allow the general public to use them

There is an unofficial Linux launcher that can run the Android build


One of the nice side effects of not playing video games anymore is I don't have to touch anything from Microsoft with a 10' pole.


It doesn't work in Wine? Or maybe that's too annoying to deal with.


No it doesn’t. It’s a UWP app with DRMs everywhere.

Although there is an unofficial Linux launcher capable of running Bedrock natively using the embedded machine code in the Android version but it requires to buy the game one more time from the Google play store.


The PC version of Bedrock edition is only available from the relatively locked down Microsoft Store.


Ah, game over




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: