Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
No rules: Illegal cabins with million-dollar views of Portland (koin.com)
16 points by zw123456 on April 10, 2023 | hide | past | favorite | 13 comments



> The couple is concerned for the people living with no services [...] Scaramella estimates he’s called or complained to different government agencies “30, 40” times.

That is an awful lot of concern!


Real good samaritans they must be!


https://archive.is/rXCfA For those with regional blocking


When I load it, the title starts with

"Portland homeless cabins with million dollar..."

so I guess now you know what kind of article to expect.


I wonder if squatting rights come into this at some point. The railroad may regret deferring this for so long.


>I wonder if squatting rights come into this at some point.

Adverse possession is complicated, according to https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/who-can-claim-proper... it takes ten years. Article says they've been doing it for five years, but if it's different people, presumably the time resets.

>The railroad may regret deferring this for so long.

On the other hand, article seems to indicate the railroad is not particularly interested in this land. Perhaps they just want to let other people deal with it and give it up.


Railroad land is specifically exempted from adverse possession under Oregon law.

The legal gray area seems to be that it’s not clear where the railroad land begins because it’s determined by the shoreline which fluctuates with the water level.

Although Union Pacific probably has enough authority to evict the squatters. It sounds like nobody wants the expense and political fallout of dealing with the problem.


Seems to me like railroads these days are burdened by lots of expensive infrastructure and are chronically underfunded. It's hard to care about everything if there's always too much on your plate.


Also a possibility!


[flagged]


I don't think a LLM is the best judge in that case.


I'm all for rule of law and property rights, but this seems like something humans have done throughout time and wary of saying it's wrong.


Well then it's not a million dollar view is it.

I'm sure that makes those people who overpaid for their view sad, but other people enjoying the same view isn't theft of "their" view. They can all enjoy it together.


> This content is not available in your country/region

Ironic given koin.com maybe like κοινός (koinós -- "common, general, available")




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: