Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don’t think you read my initial comment fully.

You don’t need to believe in any religion, though even theists are very selective followers. The point is to use philosophy from religions/etc to inform your own worldview and improve your life.




I don't know why you'd think that.

My point is, why believe that philosophy has merit, or that you'd be able to distinguish the good parts from the bad parts? (And if you are able to distinguish good from bad philosophy, why would you need an existing religion as a starting point?)


Could you point me to some perfect philosophical writings?

Obviously, the authors must be beyond reproach in their lives. And, do ensure that everything in their writings & speech are “good” before their time, during their time, during our time, and for all future times to come.

Your other point seems to be that it’s better to avoid all this, and start from scratch. It’s good for you that you are able to inform yourself of everything with no materials. The rest of us need something to go off of.


> Could you point me to some perfect philosophical writings? Obviously, the authors must be beyond reproach in their lives. And, do ensure that everything in their writings & speech are “good” before their time, during their time, during our time, and for all future times to come.

I have a lot more faith in an imperfect source that acknowledges itself as such than a source that purports to be perfect but isn't.


So all you need is a disclaimer somewhere? You can’t just assume one like a rational thinker should?

Something tells me you’re not arguing in good faith, so I’ll stop engaging.


I can't assume a disclaimer that contradicts what's explicitly in the main body of the work, no.

Religious philosophy is generally embedded in a paradigm where that religion is correct, and where scripture in particular is perfect and infallible. So it's not at all obvious to say that you can pull value from it outside that paradigm.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: